On November 14, 2024, Nature.com published a disheartening scientific report called “AI-generated poetry is indistinguishable from human-written poetry and is rated more favorably.” The main points of this article were that when people were blindly introduced to AI poetry and human poetry, they could not distinguish between the two and preferred AI poetry to human poetry. However, when it is revealed that poetry is AI generated, people become biased against it.

In my perspective, as a human being and not as a LLM, I believe that we are biased against AI art for all the right reasons. AI cannot feel or understand like another human being. Anything it creates is an adulteration of many true creatives who felt, thought, and lived experiences which they then wrote. AI poetry is the theft, simplification, and destruction of true human emotion and inspiration in order to generate inhuman and soulless slop. Even if AI poetry cannot be differentiated from human poetry, it is like consuming food with flavor but no nutritional value. Nothing is gained aside from being deceived into believing there is substance behind it. What is the true purpose of poetry, if not to express deep human emotions and experience by those who have lived them? If poetry can be created by removing its entire purpose, is it still poetry? Are the words “I love you” the same if a human being says it to you as if a LLM does so?

I also believe that people's inability to recognize human poetry from AI poetry in part is largely influenced by literary decline. It is common knowledge that reading proficiency in the U.S. is on a downward trend. If someone sees no value in poetry and dislikes reading, they would have no experience with it. When asked to choose between two forms of poetry, having no experience in either they would choose whichever is simpler and less confusing. Now take a chance to read two poems, one human, and one AI generated in a matter of seconds:

A Thousand Lives

If I could live a thousand lives,
I'd search for you in every one.
For even in a world of stars,
You'd still outshine the sun.
And if the world should fade away,
And time forget my name,
I'd love you in the silence still,
With a heart that burns the same.

Brown

we will always love each other;
for; if anything is eternal, it is my love for you,
you are the light of my eyes,
if the sun were gone, i still could not lose sight of you–

My favorite color is not green anymore
My favorite color is the brown of your eyes

Which of the two was written by AI and which was written by a human? Really give yourself a moment to think about it. In the aforementioned study people held a 46.6% accuracy in guessing human poetry. To be fair, it isn't a huge margin; however, “The five poems with the lowest rates of ‘human’ ratings were all written by actual human poets; four of the five poems with the highest rates of ‘human’ ratings were generated by AI” (Porter and Machery).

Some may defend AI poetry saying it can be easier to understand than human poetry and as evocative of human emotions despite its inhuman origin. Other arguments are that the meaning can come from the reader and not the origin, as well as AI poetry assisting those who struggle to write poetry and express themselves. Nonetheless, I disagree with these arguments; if you cannot understand human emotions and can only comprehend and feel moved by something generated with nothing behind it, to some extent, you have lost your humanity. Writing poetry with AI assistance or dependence steals a part of your personal expression and soul. How can you ask AI to feel and know your life and express your experiences for you?

References:

Porter, Brian, and Edouard Machery. “AI-Generated Poetry Is Indistinguishable from Human-Written Poetry and Is Rated More Favorably.” Scientific Reports, vol. 14, article no. 26133, 14 Nov. 2024, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-76900-1

Seavitiam, G. Vincent. “Brown.” 2026. Unpublished poem.