For the duration of my senior year in high school up until my second semester in college, I kept a journal. As has every other male I’ve encountered who has also kept a journal, I bristled at the thought of it being a “diary”. Which has, of course, misogynistic undertones; our journals were repositories for our deepest and darkest secrets, incisive critiques of American society never before written, and unmatched prose waiting to be discovered by a snooping family member after our untimely death as someone world-famous, although famous for what exactly remained unclear (à la Kafka and Pessoa). It was, crucially, not the hysteric ramblings of trivial, immaterial matters such as gossip about our friends and which people are crushing on whom, vis-à-vis Dork Diaries (which I read the whole series of in 5th grade because 11-year-old me thought it would grant me unfettered access to the elusive Female Psyche; unsurprisingly, this access was never realized, but I did end up thoroughly enjoying the books).
Although I liked to think my journal resembled the former, it, naturally, resembled the latter. I would write extensive lamentations of my current predicaments, whether it was a bad grade on a test, a perceived slight by a close friend, trying to figure out whether someone was crushing on me (and vice versa), and, as I suspect is also the case for anyone who has taken care to diligently write in a journal, truly astonishing amounts of self-loathing (In Joan Didion’s essay On Keeping a Notebook, she writes “Keepers of private notebooks are a different breed altogether, lonely and resistant rearrangers of things, anxious malcontents, children afflicted apparently at birth with some presentiment of loss”.) It became something of a ritual for me: something ostensibly bad would happen in my life, I would write for 30 minutes about the minutiae of everything and anything that led to that incident, the intractable evil that resided within whomever or whatever wronged me, and feel better about myself for an altogether insignificant amount of time. At the time, I rationalized it as getting my emotions out; in the ubiquitous therapy-speak culture we are all inured to, journaling is a central tenet of self-help. Just write down your ails, and you will feel better! is exhorted to everyone with ears to hear and eyes to see. What escaped me at the time was that this was unhealthy. It never occurred to me that, perhaps, angrily listing everything bad about my life and indulging in complaining about it was an ineffective coping mechanism, and a surefire way to ingrain a learned helplessness into my inner-monologue.
Eventually, I began to like writing about how much I disliked myself. When I could no longer write about the banal events of my day, I always knew I could turn against myself for infinite writing inspiration. If I could just write enough about the potential causes and symptoms of my misdeeds, I would somehow rid myself of those causes and symptoms. Accordingly, I would magically become a person of enviable virtue, a dutifully Reformed person. As one might expect, I never became the person of enviable virtue I sought after.
One might be compelled to list every bad thing about themselves and the people around them because it might reveal why someone and/or something acted a certain way. This rarely happens, though. Insight into your sickness is not absolution–after all, you are just writing down your problems, not acting upon them. You can compile a detailed list of everything wrong with your broken down car: a failing battery, snapped clutch cables, faulty spark plugs, but until you actually fix the car, the car remains broken.
In brief moments of lucidity, I would recognize this error in methodology. On May 26, 2026, in between a lengthy condemnation of myself and those whom I disliked, I wrote “It is not beyond me that writing endlessly about this is not healthy.” This was a thought offered by what I like to imagine as the superego wresting control over my conscience from the id, which promptly lost control of it.
I also realized that the periods in time in which I was the happiest, there were several month long gaps in my journal. My life, according to the journal, did not exist during that timeframe. Conversely, when I was the most depressed, I would incessantly complain to the journal about the circumstances of my life, and my journal entries became much more frequent and far longer. I am not positing that there is a causal link between the two, but it is certainly also the case that taking it upon myself to endlessly complain in my journal–which I began regarding as a near-sentient being–was not entirely helpful.
I am not advocating for the complete abolition of journaling. Despite the aforementioned criticism, I actually do believe there are myriad ways in which writing down the banal happenings, the problems, the half-baked theories of the universe into a journal is beneficial: One, you become a better writer. The writing advice that “the only way to get better at writing is to write” applies here. Two, when practiced in moderation, writing down your lamentations can be healthy. It is not, and never will be, the same thing as confiding in a real-life friend about your situation–when writing down your own thoughts, one has a tendency to make themselves the irrevocable hero of their own story, as does anyone who is grappling with a situation in which they are, inarguably, in the wrong–but having a physical manifestation of your conscience can force you to reckon with what you are thinking; one may think “I am not in the wrong for stealing a book from the library” because of the self-justifications floating around in one’s head (eg. “It was $25.99 on thriftbooks.com! Who in the world would pay that price? An idiot would, that’s who; and if there is one thing I am not, it’s an idiot!”)–when that thought is on paper, stripped of all context and emotional contours, one might realize that, in fact, stealing a book from a library is a bad thing to do.
I do not write in my journal anymore, nor have I ever reread it. I have tried to sit down and write, but I can never summon the desire. Rereading is a different issue altogether; it feels like breaking an arcane, inviolable rule that I would not be able to come back from. Perhaps it is that in beginning to regard it as a near-sentient being, rereading it would feel like a violation of its privacy, as if my thoughts had had their ownership transferred to the journal. Or, perhaps it is just that what I have in there is too embarrassing to face, and my subconscious is saving me from even more self-loathing (this time retroactive). I like to think of myself as relatively laid-back, but seeing page upon page of my anger over insignificant things is something I think would fundamentally alter my self-conception; back then, it felt like my problems were the end of the world. In retrospect, I doubt they’d assume the same emotional valence. Actually, I think the current-me would regard the past-me as painfully lame. I do not feel like disliking the past-me in that way. I feel an allegiance to him as one has to a guilty-pleasure song; it may be annoying, and it may be embarrassing to admit a part of you resonates with it, but, internally, one has no choice but to stand by it. Ultimately, I think both options are equally plausible.
Keeping a journal is, above all, tiring. Writing about yourself for pages upon pages is fun for a while; we are all our own favorite topic. But, when you begin to realize that even after listening to the people telling you journaling will help solve your all-consuming, irresistible despair, very little in your life actually changes. The habitual journal writer may be able to describe their malcontents with frightening precision, but, in a journal that is only for them to see, it only serves to intensify their issues. When the little voice in your head gets sick of soothing your eternal woes, the result is profoundly debilitating.